Food: from commodity to commons
The ride will be easier if we halt the depletion of resources and the degradation of nature and build a regenerative food system now, before we are faced with the possibility of worrying whether we will get any food at all before going to bed.
## The Roots of Our Food System: Commercialization, Energy, Demographics, and a Moral Compass
### The Web of Commercialization
Today's food system is deeply rooted in the commercialization of both food production and its resources. Markets, once mainly used to sell surplus goods, now dominate every aspect of food, from farm to fork. Farmers are incentivized to specialize, relying on others for inputs like seeds and livestock, resulting in a decline of diversified farms. As farms merge and mechanize to cut costs, fewer people are involved in food production, leading to abandoned farmlands, increased imports, and a loss of local agricultural knowledge.The negative consequences trickle down. Farmers, pressured by competition, are forced into high production practices that prioritize yields over environmental or social sustainability. This commercialization, in concert with fossil fuel reliance, has dramatically increased labor productivity, reducing the agricultural workforce while increasing pressure on remaining farmers.### The Interwoven Threads of Energy and DemographicsThe shift to fossil fuel-dependent farming enabled productivity growth, but it also intensified the environmental impact of food production. High fuel costs stress farmers, who have less capital to invest in more sustainable practices. Meanwhile, as populations grow and dietary habits shift, the demand for food outpaces production. To meet this demand, more land is being converted to agriculture, even as existing farmland suffers from degradation and pollution.### Corporate Control and the Myth of Consumer ChoiceIn an era where "the market" is seen as the solution to most problems, consumers are hailed as the ultimate drivers of the food system. However, this narrative is flawed. Historical and cultural factors have shaped our preferences more than economic incentives. Beyond personal choices, the system itself is dominated by major corporations, limiting consumer influence. Ethical and sustainable consumerism, while laudable, has limited effectiveness because corporations set the rules.### Externalizing Costs and the Failure of Market MechanismsUnresolved externalities, like environmental degradation, health risks, and animal suffering, are characteristic of the current food system. Despite decades of advocacy for internalizing these costs through policies like taxes and regulations, few countries have taken meaningful steps. Instead, these societal costs are typically borne by taxpayers, communities, and future generations. This failure highlights the inadequacy of relying solely on market mechanisms to ensure a sustainable and equitable food system.### The Role of States and Industry: Shaping the Food LandscapeGovernments and food corporations play significant roles in shaping the food system. Government policies, including subsidies, food safety regulations, environmental standards, and dietary recommendations, directly and indirectly influence farming practices. Industry players, including seed, food processing, and retail giants, have consolidated power, dictating production methods and constraining choices for farmers and consumers. As a result, our food system has become increasingly centralized and controlled by a handful of powerful actors.### A Moral Imperative: Rebuilding a Sustainable and Equitable Food SystemThe current food system is unsustainable and inequitable, threatening planetary health and human well-being. Addressing these challenges requires a fundamental transformation, prioritizing the welfare of humans and the environment. We need to depart from the current market-centric approach and reassert ethics and values as guiding principles.Limiting the negative impacts of commercialization, reducing energy dependence, and stabilizing population growth are crucial steps. Public support for sustainable farming practices, investment in ecological infrastructure, and reforms to reduce corporate concentration are essential.Beyond these practical measures, a shift in our collective mindset is necessary. Food, an emblem of sustainability and community, should no longer be reduced to commodities. Embracing equity, compassion for animals, and environmental stewardship must guide our food choices and shape the future of our food system.